28 April 2010

I agree with Nick.

A selection of thoughts and influences i've collected over the course of this general election run-in so far.



- If we end up with a hung parliament, which MP should we start with?

- Take care of the credence you give to what you read, watch and listen to. Rupert Murdoch controls 40% of British media and will not be looking to entertain notions of impartiality. He is a fervent conservative party supporter due to the assistance their policies will give him as a man in big business.

- Check this link, play with the toy and tell me we're not in need of electoral reform. Then ask yourself who is it that is offering the most significant electoral and political reform.

- Vote for change, vote conservative. Isn't that an oxymoron?

- The hustings (candidate's debate) held by Wakefield Baptist Church exposed the tory candidate to be considerably incapable. Hysterically and offensively incapable actually. The labour candidate (and current MP) is, as an individual, very convincing, but sadly she couldn't escape the state the country has got into on her party's watch. The lib-dem candidate came over much as the rest of his party are doing at the moment: energised, creative, modern, open and credible. The green party candidate did her job; she raised the green agenda well and made intelligent insights on contemporary society and politics without looking in danger of being elected.

- If you have the opportunity before 6th May (not that it will be rendered useless after that date, but it might be a good influence before it) i would heartily recommend getting hold of Mark Thomas' 'The People's Manifesto'. It's a few quid and a lightening quick read. It takes a very creative approach to lots of the issues on the political agenda, as well a several that really should be there but aren't. Oh, and did i mention it's wet-yourself-funny?

Other thoughts:
- The life injected into British politics by the TV debates.
- Constant surprise at the degree of apathy that continues to exist, perpetuated by the incredibly misguided notion that politics is an optional subject within society, rather than the construction of society.
- The lack of political education received by my generation.
- The question of the place of nationalism before God.
- The way moments, like calling members of your electorate bigoted, will swing this election

4 comments:

tim f said...

Although my government supports electoral reform, I don't. I like first-past-the-post. Proportionality isn't everything; accountability is more important.

The bigoted thing: it's typical that you get in most trouble for telling the truth.

At the end of the day I still think a class vote is more important than coming over as modern or energised. Labour's policies are more redistributive than the Lib Dems. Of course I'm tribal Labour, but that's because Labour side with the poorest and most oppressed more than any other party and mainly because of our institutional link to the organised working class.

And which MP should we hang? Toss up between Nadine Dorries and Frank Field.

andy amoss said...

Hey Tim,

I get that you're "tribal labour", and i appreciate your acknowledgement of that.

I think the modern thing is more important than you give it credit for. Perhaps i should have used the word contemporary instead. I think the way labour, and the conservatives, are attempting to frame issues is out-moded.

As far as labour's alignment with the organised working class is concerned, i'd like to go with you on that except class, and class distinctions, have changed. And the poorest aren't organised. Lib-Dems now appear to find themselves in that corner.

You're right about the bigot stuff. The best, but least spoken comment i've heard was that the only thing Brown did wrong was in not sticking to his guns.

I must confess also that i've been disappointed in the apparent demise of The Provisional BBC. I was looking forward to some excellent commentary on election haps and mis-haps. I guess your too busy campaigning yourself.

Catch you soon.

andy amoss said...

Also, proportionality isn't everything... if you can win by not having the biggest proportion.

Anonymous said...

On class distinctions, I think the death of the working class is very much exaggerated but that's a topic for another day.

Will continue this discussion after the election. Only thing I'll say now is that there is no way the Lib Dems are in the corner of the poorest and disorganised - their tax proposals hurt the very poorest. Most of the billions they give away end up in the pockets of well to-do people who are helped by raising the threshold at which you pay tax, and people who currently don't reach the existing threshold are not helped at all. Plus they pay for it by getting rid of tax credits, which, while imperfect, do at least redistribute a lot more money to the poorest and particularly to families than the Lib Dem proposals would.

Tim